Nintendo Adapter Box

[lackyluuk]

@acris
I have changed global.inputdriver=auto to sdl2 and udev. Same behaviour, SNES and NES controller still only work in ES.

Here are my support.sh files:

• Only adapterbox connected to recalbox (no controllers connected to box):
  http://www52.zippyshare.com/v/VAAnNWtd/file.html

• SNES controller connected to adapterbox (Works fine in ES):
  http://www52.zippyshare.com/v/hbrvTfUM/file.html

[acris]

@lackyluuk
try this idea :

mount -o remount,rw /

edit this file : /etc/modprobe.d./usbhid.conf

add theses lines at the end :

#raphnet.net 4nes4snes v1.5
options usbhid quirks=0x289b:0x0003:0x040

save and reboot your raspberry.
Try SNES gamepad.

but I think theses adapters need patch kernel.

[lackyluuk]

@acris
Thanks for your help. Unfortunately it does not work. I saw that the 4NES4SNES adapter is already in the /usbhid.conf file.
Could it be possible that the new version v1.5 is the problem?

Is there anything else I could try to figure out?

[acris]

@lackyluuk
not it s another
your id vendor and id product are differents, you need to add my informations and try if you didn t do it.

https://github.com/recalbox/recalbox-buildroot/blob/master/board/recalbox/fsoverlay/etc/modprobe.d/usbhid.conf#L5

oh not raphnet need a kernel patch too

@Substring , @ian57

[lackyluuk]

@acris yes I have tried your info, but no luck

[acris]

i think kernel patch is missing in recalbox 4.1

[Substring]

Ni idea if it requires a patch to the kernel, i don't think so as it works fine in es, right ?

[lackyluuk]

@Substring yes, in ES it does what it should. But no response at all in a game. This only occurs with the 4NES4SNES adapter. The one for N64 works fine.
I have connected these two adapters with a small usb hub.

[Substring]

@lackyluuk ok, this is what you should do :

• test pads with evtest, i think they should work
• same goes with sdl2-jstest
  => if both of them work, then it's a retroarch problem
• out of curiosity, try to remap the pads in retroarch so that we can see if retroarch can see them afterall

Give a try to https://github.com/recalbox/recalbox-os/issues/1244#issuecomment-2981808465 because it has an updated retroarch version, i know i had to rewrite 1 patch regarding inputs, so maybe that would do.

Still, if it works in ES, it means it works with SDL and linux kernel, so that is a retroarch problem. You could eventually try some non retroarch emulators with these pads (mupen scummvm, advancemame, reicast)

[lackyluuk]

@Substring thanks a lot! I will try these points and give a feedback then.

[lackyluuk]

@Substring I have found some patches for this problem I think. They are from raphnet itself. Do you think this could work?

http://www.raphnet-tech.com/support/retropie/

(And we should let him know about recalbox, haha ;))

[Substring]

@lackyluuk 4.4 kernel doesn't seem to require these patches. Anyway please test what I suggested. The quriks are not necessary (or were they already applied when you submitted your support archive ?).

So, still, i believe it's a RA problem.

[lackyluuk]

@Substring Yes of course, I will test it tonight when I am home.
The quirks from @acris were not implemented when I created the support archives.

Yes, the quirks from the second point are only for pre-4.2 kernel. But do you think that the first point "Issue with initial values" (the 3 patches) is also covered through the updated kernel?
http://www.raphnet-tech.com/support/retropie/usbhid_iostart.diff
http://www.raphnet-tech.com/support/retropie/usbhid_start_before_connect.diff
http://www.raphnet-tech.com/support/retropie/jsdev_initial_value.diff

[Substring]

@lackyluuk your controller does work with ES, so i'd say yes. I'll have a look at the kernel code though

[lackyluuk]

@Substring

Results:

• evtest works super fine

• sdl2-jstest works fine as well

• Config in retroarch not successful

• TADAA: I have tested Mupen and the SNES pad worked even in-game... so definitely a retroarch problem

• Installed the unofficial new version with retroarch 1.5 --> no success

Maybe let them know about this 4NES4SNES v1.5 adapter?

..pheww..

[Substring]

@lackyluuk even switching to the input mode to sdl (or sdl2 i'm not sure) did not help ?

[lackyluuk]

@Substring I have tried 'udev' and 'sdl2' with the previous version. I should try it tonight with the new verzion again. This went out of my mind..I'll let you know

[Substring]

@lackyluuk I think it won't help ... i should eventually ask retroarch (the problem is that we slightly patch RA regarding inputs).

Please send me a reminder next week regarding this issue, this week is a busy IRL recalbox week (we're all going to HFS Summer 3 and will be having a conference there to talk about Recalbox).

[lackyluuk]

@Substring alright. I will try it anyway, just curious
Ok, great! Aw, it would be nice to go there as well and meet the recalbox team in real
But it's a bit too far -.-